Whatever was taken, the first steps are the same: make sure you are safe, document what is missing, report the theft to police and get a report number, and notify your insurer. Those steps matter because most property crime is never reported, and the police report number is the record that insurers, stolen-property registries and recovering agencies rely on.
First steps for any theft
Tick each step as you finish it; your progress is saved in this browser only. For a paper copy, download the free PDF.
Download the free PDF PDF, 109 KB · printable, with space for report numbers
Share this checklist: Share on X Share on Facebook
Right away
Within 24 hours
This week
Follow up
This checklist is general information, not legal advice. Agencies change their procedures, so confirm each step with the organization named.
Choose what was stolen
What to do when your domain name is stolen
A calm, ordered guide for business owners and domain investors whose domain was transferred without authorization.
What to do if your identity is stolen
A calm, ordered checklist for reporting identity theft, protecting your credit and repairing the accounts that were misused.
What to do if your car is stolen
A calm, ordered checklist for the hours and days after a vehicle is taken from its owner.
What to do when a social media or email account is hijacked
Take back the email account first, then the profiles that depend on it, and shut every door the attacker used.
What to do after a SIM swap or phone number port-out
Your phone number is a key to your accounts; get it back, lock it, and change every lock it opened.
What to do if your phone is stolen
A stolen phone is a key to your accounts; lock the device, lock the number, and then change every lock it opens.
What to do if your bike or e-bike is stolen
The serial number is what turns a bike into evidence; find it, report it, and get it in front of the people who check.
What to do when a package or mail is stolen
Confirm what happened, put the loss on record with the right party, and protect any checks or account documents that went missing with it.
What to do if your wallet, cards or checks are stolen
Close off the money first, then replace your IDs and watch for anyone using your name.
What to do if your passport is stolen
Report it first so no one else can use it, then replace it the way your location allows.
What to do if a gun is stolen, and how to check if a gun is stolen
A stolen firearm can be returned only if police can identify it, so the serial number is the most important fact you hold.
What to do if art, antiques or collectibles are stolen
A stolen artwork is recovered when someone can recognize it, so the description you give now is what brings it home.
What to do if your cryptocurrency is stolen
Crypto transfers are rarely reversible, so protect what is left, preserve the evidence and report it quickly.
Why reporting a theft matters
Most theft in the United States never reaches police. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, Criminal Victimization, 2024, only 30.5% of property crimes were reported to police in 2024. Reporting rates were 75.0% for motor vehicle theft, 40.7% for burglary and trespassing, and 25.4% for other theft. In other words, about seven in ten property crimes go unreported.
The gap may be wider than that. In Victimization Estimates from the Redesigned NCVS Instrument, 2024, BJS measured property crime at 127.6 per 1,000 households, 31% higher than the legacy questionnaire's 97.6, and found only 25.0% of property crimes reported to police (18.5% for other household theft). The National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS, the federal household survey that counts crimes whether or not they were reported) is the reason anyone knows how much theft goes unrecorded.
An unreported theft is invisible to every system built to return property. The police report is what puts a serial number into law-enforcement records, what supports an insurance claim, and what lets the agency that eventually recovers an item trace it back to its owner. Reporting does not guarantee recovery. Without a report, recovery is largely a matter of luck.
Recovery odds by type of property
What was taken largely decides whether it comes back. Few agencies publish recovery rates by category, but two state reports do. The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation reported that Oklahoma recovered $87,498,101 of $344,617,976 in stolen property in 2024, a 25.4% recovery rate. Within that total the rates diverged sharply:
- 53.5% for vehicles and accessories
- 12.5% for weapons
- 7.5% for electronics
- 5.8% for merchandise
- 1.2% for currency, ID and information
Arkansas shows the same pattern. A 2024 statewide table published by the Arkansas Department of Public Safety reports that 22.29% of $217,366,193 in stolen property was recovered; automobiles were recovered at 61.84% and firearms at 14.53%. (The table does not print the state name; the attribution rests on the agency's website.)
Vehicles come back far more often than anything else because each carries a vehicle identification number (VIN, the unique code assigned to every vehicle), is registered with the state, and can be checked by any officer in seconds. The California Highway Patrol 2024 Vehicle Theft Fact Sheet reports that 149,080 of 176,230 vehicles stolen in California in 2024 were recovered, an 84.59% recovery rate.
Bicycles sit near the other end. In a survey of 1,823 US and Canadian theft victims, Patterns in Bike Theft and Recovery found that only 15% of stolen bicycles were recovered; police returned 34% of the recovered bikes, and 27% of recovered bikes had been listed for sale online. The lesson repeats across every category: property with a recorded, unique identifier is far more likely to return than property without one. Cash and unrecorded electronics rarely come back.
What police can and cannot do
Police take the report, assign a report number and, for property with a unique serial number, can enter the item into the National Crime Information Center (NCIC, the FBI's stolen-property and wanted-person system, which only law enforcement can search). Once an item is entered, an officer who checks that serial number during a traffic stop, an investigation or a recovery can see that it was reported stolen and who reported it. Police also follow leads such as video, a named suspect or a tracked location, and they are the right people to retrieve property from someone else.
Police cannot do everything. Many departments cannot assign an investigator to every low-value theft that has no leads. An item without a serial number or distinctive markings is difficult to enter or match in any database. Police do not process insurance claims, and a disagreement over who owns an item can become a civil matter for the courts rather than a criminal one.
Ask the officer three questions before the conversation ends: what happens next, who to contact with new information, and how to get a copy of the report. If you later locate your property, give the location to police instead of retrieving it yourself. Confronting a seller or occupant puts you at risk and can complicate the case.
Insurance basics
Insurance is often the most reliable route to being made whole, even when the item itself never returns. Policies differ widely, so treat the points below as general orientation, not insurance advice. Read your own policy or ask your agent or insurer.
- Homeowners and renters policies often cover personal property stolen from the home, and many also cover property stolen elsewhere, subject to a deductible and coverage limits.
- Auto policies generally cover theft of the vehicle only when the policy includes comprehensive coverage. Personal belongings taken from inside a car may fall under a homeowners or renters policy instead.
- Special limits commonly apply to categories such as jewelry, firearms, cash, collectibles and electronics unless those items were separately listed on the policy.
- Deadlines and documentation are set by the policy. Insurers commonly ask for a police report number and proof of ownership.
Notify the insurer promptly even if you are unsure the loss exceeds your deductible, and ask how the insurer treats a notice of loss compared with a filed claim. Keep every letter and email in your log.
How to prove ownership
Recovered property is returned to the person who can prove it is theirs, and insurers pay claims on the same basis. The strongest proof combines three things: a unique identifier, a record of purchase, and an image of the item in your possession.
- Serial numbers. Record the serial number of every phone (and its IMEI, the International Mobile Equipment Identity number that identifies the handset to carriers), laptop, camera, tool, bicycle frame and firearm you own.
- Receipts and records. Keep receipts, invoices, order confirmations, warranty registrations, appraisals and card statements that show the purchase.
- Photos and video. Photograph each item, including engravings, scratches, stickers and other marks that set it apart from identical models.
- Registrations. Vehicle titles, bicycle registry entries and, for domain names, registrar account records, invoices and WHOIS or RDAP history (the public registration records showing who held a domain and when) all establish ownership.
Store copies somewhere other than the items they describe. A serial number list saved only on a stolen laptop proves nothing. Cloud storage, an email to yourself or a printed copy kept away from home all work.
Ownership records matter most for valuables that are hard to tell apart. The art and collectibles checklist explains Object ID, the international standard for describing a work so it can be identified if it resurfaces.
When the stolen item holds your identity or accounts
A stolen wallet, phone or laptop is two losses: the object, and the access it carries. The Identity Theft Resource Center, 2026 Trends in Identity Report found that among people whose physical items were stolen and later misused, 71% experienced account takeover and 44% new account fraud. Stolen phones and tablets led to account takeover in every case reported, although that finding rests on 14 individuals in a small, self-selected sample.
Treat the data as stolen along with the device. Change passwords for accounts the device was signed in to, starting with email, contact your wireless carrier, and consider a credit freeze with each of the three nationwide credit bureaus. You can review your credit reports through AnnualCreditReport.com, and IdentityTheft.gov provides recovery plans for stolen identity documents. The guides to identity theft, hacked accounts and SIM swaps cover those steps in detail.
Guides for specific types of theft
Each guide starts with a checklist ordered the way a victim should act, followed by an explanation of how that kind of theft works and what recovery looks like.
- Domain name theft: what to do when a domain is transferred out of your account without authorization.
- Identity theft: what to do when someone uses your personal information to open accounts or commit fraud.
- Stolen vehicles: what to do when a car, truck, motorcycle or trailer is taken.
- Hacked accounts: what to do when an email, social media or financial account is taken over.
- SIM swaps: what to do when your phone number is moved to someone else's SIM card.
- Stolen phones: lock, locate and erase the device, then block the IMEI.
- Stolen bicycles and e-bikes: put the serial number in front of police, registries and resale buyers.
- Package and mail theft: carrier claims, the seller and the Postal Inspection Service.
- Stolen wallets, cards and checks: close off the money first, then replace IDs.
- Stolen passports: report it so it cannot be used, then replace it at home or abroad.
- Stolen firearms: report the serial number to police and check state reporting rules.
- Stolen art and collectibles: describe it to the Object ID standard and get it into the stolen art databases.
- Stolen cryptocurrency: secure what remains, record every transaction hash and report quickly.
For anything else, the universal checklist above applies, and the official lookup tools page lists the registries available for each type of property. Stolen domain names that meet our verification standard are listed at the Confirmed Stolen domain list.
Frequently asked questions
Should I report a theft to police if the item was not worth much?
Yes, in most cases. A report creates the record insurers and registries ask for, lets police connect your theft to others in the area, and gives a recovering agency a way to return the item. Many departments accept online reports for lower-value thefts.
What information do I need to file a police report for stolen property?
Bring a description of each item, serial numbers, approximate values, receipts or photos, when and where the theft happened, and any footage or witness details. Ask for the report number before you leave or hang up.
What are the chances of getting stolen property back?
It depends on the item. Oklahoma recovered 25.4% of stolen property by value in 2024, including 53.5% for vehicles and accessories but only 7.5% for electronics and 1.2% for currency, ID and information. Property with a recorded serial number is far more likely to return.
Does homeowners or renters insurance cover stolen items?
Many homeowners and renters policies cover theft of personal property, subject to a deductible and limits, and some categories such as jewelry or electronics may have lower limits. Read your own policy or ask your insurer, because coverage varies.
I found my stolen item listed for sale online. What should I do?
Do not contact the seller or try to buy it back yourself. Save screenshots and the listing link, then send them to the officer handling your report, quoting your report number.
How can I check whether an item has been reported stolen?
Use the official registry for that type of property, such as a VIN check for vehicles, the CTIA Stolen Phone Checker for phones, or Bike Index for bicycles. The lookup tools page lists each one with its limits.
Sources
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Criminal Victimization, 2024
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Victimization Estimates from the Redesigned NCVS Instrument, 2024
- Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation, Selected Findings: Property Loss and Recovered 2024
- Arkansas Department of Public Safety, 2024 Value of Property Stolen and Recovered, State
- California Highway Patrol, 2024 Vehicle Theft Fact Sheet
- Patterns in Bike Theft and Recovery, Findings
- Identity Theft Resource Center, 2026 Trends in Identity Report
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center
- FTC IdentityTheft.gov
- AnnualCreditReport.com